Sunday, March 05, 2006

Termite Flashing: Stainless is not painless

After chosing the exact location for our house, we decided to remove four trees that could potentially damage the house if they ever fell over. I had special plans for the most beatiful tree... a northern red oak. But much to my horror, less than 100 feet from our house, inside the trunk of this otherwise sound oak tree, we exposed a thriving termite colony. (The first functioning termite colony I'd ever seen)

Needless to say, this got my attention - somehow our house would need to be protected from these hideous creatures. Because I had built a pond downstream of our house site, poisoning the soil around our house as a means of temporarily fending off termites was not a viable option. (although many people still insist that I should poison all of the ground around my house!) In the course of pouring through various drawings of foundation details, I came across a mechanical termite shield. The concept sounds simple... a continuous metal flashing that seperates the wood of your house from the soil and foundation beneath it.

Of course termites can and do fly, but the flashing supposedly exploits the termite's basic need to return to the earth (for water? to breed?). Of course, termites could probably traverse the metal flashing, but when they do, they do it within mud tunnels, to avoid exposure (to the sun? to light?). So long as the entire perimeter of the flashing is visibly exposed to the homeowner, a periodic inspection will reveal any "breaches in the security system" and the homeowner can engage the termites at the appropriate location before they can inflict extensive damage.

In the course of trying to incorporate this seemingly elegant solution into my foundation details, I found out why it is not widely used... it's anything but elegant to implement!!! The first bad news is that steel and aluminum are not recommended as flashing material because they corrode (via galvanic reaction) in the presence of the copper compounds found in all pressure treated wood. Copper and stainless are said to be appropriate materials (although copper can corrode in the presence of some types of concrete, and stainless must technically be passivated stainless in order to be compatible.) I chose stainless because I felt more comfortable welding stainless than soldering copper (bad assumption!?), I think it has the potential to last longer than copper (although both should outlast me), and I could not (at the time) visualize how to pass the (steel) foundation anchors through copper termite flashing to the timbers and maintain a seal that would not corrode itself.

My mental model of termite flashing is analogous to a prophylactic... in other words, if you can't get 100% coverage, then why bother, because it only takes one hole for the termites to gain entry to your house. Some foundation details that I've seen of termite flashings implement them more like insulation - in other words, some is better than nothing and 100% coverage is not necessary. Perhaps I should have adopted the "insulation model" instead of the "prophylactic model" of how this flashing works - it surely would have made my life a lot easier as regards termite flashing. But I just can't see how you can expect an termite (that can travel over 100 feet underground) not to find a hole in the flashing.

Details and thoughts:

1. My post-to-foundation anchors are homemade stainless steel straps that were poured 16+ inches into the concrete walls and hook under the topmost course of rebar within the concrete. Because the straps were stainless and the flashing was stainless, I was able to weld the seams everywhere the straps passed through the flashing.

2. I began with 24 gauge stainless because I thought it would be easy to work (not really - you can't bend it in a brake made for aluminum flashing - I tried and failed), I thought it would be plenty strong (true), it cost about the same as copper, and I thought I could reasonably weld it (wrong).

3. I switched to 18 gauge after the 24 gauge ran out, and the 18 gauge was 100 times easier to weld, maybe only twice as hard to work, and almost twice as expensive. Welding 18 gauge to 24 gauge was tolerable but tedious. This is what I did in order to use up the last of my 24 gauge stainless.

4. Don't forget to cap the plinths that your basement posts sit on. Termites can otherwise pass unseen through cracks in your slab right into the bottom of the posts.

5. With a Lincoln 255 MIG welder, these settings worked well for 18 gauge stainless:
.030 diameter, 308 alloy, 17 volts, 210 ipm, 25 cfh pure argon.

6. You can solder stainless, but I wouldn't advise it - Soldering stainless is more tedious than welding 24 gauge stainless. You can see in this picture though that I was able to do it (out of desperation - but then I went back to welding!). If you decide to try and solder stainless, be sure to neutralize the flux as most flux is corrosive to stainless. (I used baking soda)


7. Consider copper. My friend did, and he had much much much much less trouble than I on his cabin. timberframe with copper termite flashing Copper looks nicer too. I suppose you could use stainless post-to-foundation anchor straps and solder the joints. (not sure if stainless to copper solder connnections are viable though.) Alternatively, you could dispense with post anchor straps, and use stainless allthread to anchor your timber sill to the foundation, then use stainless washers where the allthread passes through your copper flashing. (my friend went this route, but didn't use stainless steel.)

8. I don't know what to say about finished basements... I haven't exactly figured that out myself for my own basement. I have yet to find a detail in any book of how to implement termite flashing in a finished basement (or slab on grade for that matter). The rub being... how to keep termites from travelling vertically through interior partions in the basement. For now, I have resolved to keep interior basement partion walls to a minimum, flash all interior basement partion walls, and not to fir out the interiors of the poured walls.

9. Try not to use a steel brush or hammer on your stainless. This will possibly impart tiny pieces of non-stainless steel that will keep the stainless from passivating itself. Your stainless will then rust or pit in these locations. (I have already seen it happen on my stainless)

Summary: Termite flashings are academic solutions, best suited for houses built over crawl spaces. I doubt the folks that recommend them in print actually have one on their house, and if they do, I doubt it is implemented in a comprehensive or foolproof way. Nevertheless, I found it to be the most believable non-poison means of protecting my house from termites. I wanted to try something. If it works, it should last more than 100 years and be cheaper in the long run than periodically poisoning the soil around the house. If you try it, think seriously about copper instead of stainless. If you don't use a termite flashing, take comfort in the fact that I have 4 barns, each 50 years old, all in fine shape, sitting on nothing but dry-laid stone piers.

5 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

I came across your post as I was researching blogger's experiences with Termites in their home. I had a few questions about your personal blog. What would be the best way to get in contact with you? Thanks!

Best,
Bailey Smith
baileymsmith@gmail.com

July 10, 2008 at 2:40 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Termites always have tunnels to ground in order to maintain balanced humidity within their tunnel systems, which they require - particularly in the brood chambers that house eggs and immature termites. Their brood chambers are always built underground, not in the wood.

Never let brush grow tight against a wood framed building, and make an inspection tour once a year to make sure you don't have any mud tubes crossing the foundations.

If you see termite tunnels, get a professional exterminator at least the first time. You want to entirely eliminate the colony as quickly as possible.

Carpenter ants are different - they only eat wet wood, so get rid of the leaks and the ants will leave in a year or two. Don't let leaks get to the wood and you'll never get carpenter ants.

Insect-damaged wood should be thoroughly treated with bora-care or similar borate wood preservative. It will kill the rot and mildew that you almost certainly have as well if you've got buggy wood.

The wife's an entomologist, I'm just some guy with a timber-framed house and barn that have survived infestation. Thank you for creating this site, it is very useful and inspirational.

June 27, 2009 at 10:10 AM  
Blogger oldmilwaukee said...

Great advice anonymous. So far, no termite have crossed the stainless barrier.

June 28, 2009 at 9:48 AM  
Anonymous Carl Patten said...

Nice termite flashing. It's indeed another alternative to wood preservative chemicals. But it requires a lot more sweat and money to build unless you have already the materials in your garage. Hope it works in your house.

September 9, 2011 at 8:35 AM  
Anonymous Garry said...

Australians have problems with very active termites. We have used "galvanised" flashing for a very long time in situations where there is an air space under the house.

Houses on "stumps" always have a "tin lid" on the brick or wood stumps and it's very effective. AN air space helps as it avoids dampness.

Some people say that when laying a slab, there is a chance that it can crack and termites can enter that way. Anything's possible, but its a bit of a long shot. Generally, termite flashing is very effective lasts forever and is the cheapest solution.

If you want a prophylactic and also a condom (haha) use a bitumen layer between the slab edge and the flashing and also between joins and corners.

Here's a pdf from an Australian govt department

http://www.bsa.qld.gov.au/SiteCollectionDocuments/Generic/Publications/Termite%20Management%20Systems%20-%20Advisory%20Notes%20for%20Homeowners%20and%20Builders%20Booklet.pdf

My feeling is that there is so little money in flashing that it never gets the good press it deserves. An annual toxic spray sounds so much more effective and well - it costs so much it must be good!

I'm building again soon. I'll be using flashing and .. since it is kinda underground - no earth on sides ... I'll be soaking the roof poles in a borate solution. See www.mabons.com.au and read up on PestBor or similar

November 21, 2012 at 11:51 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home